Sea Grant Aquaculture Research Program: Predicting spatial impacts of bivalve aquaculture on nutrient cycling and benthic habitat quality
Principal Investigator:Jeffrey C. Cornwell
Start/End Year:2010 to 2013
Institution:Horn Point Laboratory, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science
Co-Principal investigator:Lawrence P. Sanford, Horn Point Laboratory, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science
Strategic focus area:Sustainable natural resources of coastal Maryland
OBJECTIVES : Our primary objective is to assess off-bottom oyster and mussel aquaculture effects on surrounding sediments and nutrient regeneration processes. We seek to generate data and refine models to quantify the effects of bivalve aquaculture on the surrounding ecosystem, and to develop design guidelines to help mitigate any possible adverse effects. We will carry out our first year studies and model development at a shallow oyster aquaculture site in Chesapeake Bay, and will repeat our studies to validate the modeling approaches at a deeper mussel aquaculture site in coastal Maine in the second year. We will present our results and recommendations to coastal zone managers, and will help them learn to use these tools for guidance in locating farms in the coastal zone. We will also make our results, recommendations, and tools available to aquaculturists for optimizing bivalve stocking density, thereby helping minimize some of the adverse effects stemming from over enrichment of sediments by shellfish fecal waste. METHODOLOGY: We will work in cooperation with Marinetics oyster aquaculture farm in Chesapeake Bay, and Pemaquid Mussel Farms, a mussel farm in Maine. In Year 1 at the Marinetics site we will quantify deposition, resuspension, and dispersal of feces and pseudofeces and changes in sediment characteristics, including inorganic nutrient release and organic carbon accumulation. We will use these data to obtain a quantitative understanding of the relationships between dispersal and breakdown of particulate waste generated from shellfish aquaculture relative to the physical and sedimentological characteristics of a site and linked to seasonal variability in oyster feeding. We will integrate information on these effects, relative to the physical and sedimentological characteristics of a site, into Shellfish-DEPOMOD, and will explore several refinements of the model based on the data and our modeling experience. We will also model changes in sediment biogeochemistry associated with deposition of the particulate waste along the dispersal plume. In Year 2 we will measure the same processes at the deeper mussel aquaculture site in Maine and compare these results to predictions from our model. This will test the predicative capability of our model validation and allow us to make any necessary adjustments. Finally, we will develop a series of semi-empirical guidelines for optimizing siting of bivalve aquaculture leases within the coastal zone in a manner that minimizes adverse effects and possibly enhances benthic denitrification. RATIONALE: A major impediment to the expansion of shellfish culture is the often considerable opposition to the use of public waters due to perceived adverse environmental consequences. Until there is a better understanding of the interaction between aquaculture and the surrounding environment it will continue to be difficult to obtain the necessary permits to culture shellfish in coastal and estuarine locations in the USA. In addition, knowledge of aquaculture/environment interactions will lead to sustainable production practices which may be marketed as part of the trend towards sustainable means of food production. Development of shellfish farms is an important way to help sustain traditional lifestyles and provide jobs and incomes to coastal communities, maintaining a working waterfront where declining wild stocks of fish and shellfish are causing reduced harvest and leading to severe economic hardship. Our research addresses the Sea Grant program priority area of "smart design" methods for bivalve aquaculture and also addresses the priority of developing a planning tool to allow aquaculture farms to be located optimally in the coastal zone in a manner consistent with ecosystem-based management.
RECAP: This ongoing research project is quantifying the effects of off-bottom oyster and mussel aquaculture (i.e. on floats) on sediments and surrounding water. The researchers are working to predict the influence of oyster and mussel farms on nutrient processes and to mitigate possible adverse effects.
RELEVANCE: This ongoing research seeks to quantify the effects of bivalve aquaculture on the surrounding ecosystem and to develop design guidelines to help mitigate any possible adverse effects. An impediment to the expansion of shellfish aquaculture is the often considerable opposition to the use of public waters due to perceived adverse environmental consequences. This project also seeks to enhance knowledge of interactions between aquaculture and the environment that may lead to sustainable production practices, boost the aquaculture industry, and provide jobs and incomes to coastal communities. Another benefit may be to enhance benthic denitrification.
RESPONSE: The principal investigators of this research project are Roger I.E. Newell, Jeffrey C. Cornwell, and Lawrence P. Sanford of the University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science, Horn Point Laboratory. In this reporting period the researchers worked in cooperation with the Marinetics oyster aquaculture farm in the Chesapeake Bay. Through field studies, they quantified deposition, resuspension, and dispersal of oyster feces and pseudofeces and changes in sediment characteristics. The researchers are using these data to obtain a quantitative understanding of the relationships between dispersal and breakdown of particulate waste generated from shellfish aquaculture relative to the physical characteristics of a site and the seasonal variability of oyster feeding.
RESULTS: The researchers performed four week-long seasonal field studies to measure rates of deposition of organic nitrogen and carbon from oyster feces and pseudofeces settling underneath oyster floats. They largely completed development of a Flow 3-D model to assess water flow around and through the aquaculture sites. They can now incorporate in the model their field data on particulate waste production by oysters and mussels and the settling velocity of these various-sized particles.
The researchers have been in extensive contact with the Seafood Quality Standards Coordinator for Whole Foods Market. Whole Foods is working towards the goal of selling shellfish raised in aquaculture farms in a manner to minimize adverse ecological effects.
Owens, MS; Cornwell, JC. 2016. /*-->*/ The Benthic Exchange of O-2, N-2 and Dissolved Nutrients Using Small Core Incubations Journal of Visualized Experiments(114):1-10. doi:10.3791/54098. UM-SG-RS-2016-24.
Testa, JM; Brady, DC; Cornwell, JC; Owens, MS; Sanford, LP; Newell, CR; Suttles, SE; Newell; RIE. 2015. Modeling the impact of floating oyster (Crassostrea virginica) aquaculture on sediment-water nutrient and oxygen fluxes. Aquaculture Environment Interactions 7(3):205-222. doi:10.3354/aei00151. UM-SG-RS-2015-11.